Subgenus (Phenacolepas) H. A. Pilsbry, 1891
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-0-0-0-0)

antillarum "Shuttleworth" W. H. Dall, 1889
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-1-0-0-0)
[=Phenacolepas (Phenacolepas) hamillei (P. Fischer, 1857)]
Ref. Abbott, 1974 p 65

crenulata (W. J. Broderip, 1834) [T]
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-2-0-0-0)
Ref. Abbott, 1974 p 65

hamillei (P. Fischer, 1857)
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-3-0-0-0)
Hamille's Limpet
Ref. Amer. Fish. Soc., 1988 p 58
Syn. Phenacolepas (Phenacolepas) antillarum "Shuttleworth" W. H. Dall, 1889
Ref. Abbott, 1974 p 65 bw

magdalena W. H. Dall, 1918
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-4-0-0-0)
[=Phenacolepas (Phenacolepas) malonei E. G. Vanatta, 1912]
Ref. Abbott, 1974 p 65

malonei E. G. Vanatta, 1912
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-5-0-0-0)
Syn. Phenacolepas (Phenacolepas) magdalena W. H. Dall, 1918
Ref. Abbott, 1974 p 65
Keen, 1971 p 361 bw d

osculans (C. B. Adams, 1852)
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-6-0-0-0)
Syn. Scutellina navicelloides P. P. Carpenter, 1856 [1857]
Ref. Abbott, 1974 p 65
Keen, 1971 p 361 d

? puntarenae (O. A. L. Morch, 1860)
(5-4-1-3-1-4-0-1-3-7-0-0-0)
Ref. Keen, 1971 p 361 bw